# The non-warrantable condo other lenders couldn't close

Canonical URL: https://www.totalqualitylending.com/case-studies/non-warrantable-condo
Updated: 2026-11-04T13:56:43.606Z

## Summary

They left for a rate more than a point lower. The condo questionnaire failed nine days later. They came back and still signed on the original close date.

## Story

A borrower left us for a rate more than a point lower. Nine days later the condo questionnaire came back, it did not meet the other lender's guidelines, and nobody on that side knew what to do next. The file came back to us with the closing date unchanged.

## The deal

Two investors went under contract on a beachfront condo they planned to run as a short-term rental. They owned one rental already. They wanted 20% down, a 30-year fixed DSCR loan, and title in their LLC.

Their purchase contract had a clause most buyers never see. They had seven business days to produce a lender willing to confirm, in writing, that it would lend on that specific condominium. The seller had been through failed condo financing before and was not interested in going through it again.

We issued the pre-approval letter the day after they called.

## Why they left

Then a broker came back more than a point below our quote, with a $10,000 credit on the loan estimate. Same product we had quoted, a DSCR loan, at a number we could not match. On paper it was not a close call, and their real estate agent told them so.

Getting to a number that far below market is expensive, and the credit was there to absorb the cost. But the rate was never the risk in this file. The building was non-warrantable, and the only question that mattered was whether the condo documents would clear underwriting. A rate you never get to use is worth nothing.

They went with the broker. We told them the door stayed open and that we take transferred appraisals. What they had no way to know was the part that decided the deal. A broker uses whatever condo questionnaire its investor requires. We have our own. On a warrantable building that never comes up. Here it was everything.

## The call back

Nine days later one of the borrowers called. The condo questionnaire had come back and it did not meet the other lender's guidelines. There was no path forward on that side and no plan to find one. The seller's agent was telling everyone the property could not be financed this way and that only a lender based in the local coastal market would know how to close it. They were about to lose the condo.

By then roughly two weeks of a five-week contract period were gone.

## What actually stopped the broker

This is the part worth understanding, because it repeats across every coastal condo market in the country.

A condo project is warrantable if it meets agency guidelines on owner-occupancy, investor concentration, budget reserves, litigation, and commercial space. This one did not, which is normal for a beach building full of short-term rentals. Non-warrantable is not a defect. It just means agency money will not buy the loan, so the loan has to go somewhere else.

Every lender orders a condo questionnaire from the HOA. Not every lender has its own. A broker uses whatever form the investor behind the loan requires, and if the HOA will not answer a line on that form, the file stops there. Those forms ask for a reserve study, dates of the last structural inspection, and several items that HOA management companies along the Alabama coast routinely decline to answer, some of them because state law does not require it.

The listing agent put this in writing to us before we re-engaged. He named the specific line items the HOA would refuse, said there was no reserve study, and asked whether we still expected to close. His seller had already required in the contract that the buyer use a lender who understood the local condo situation, because he had watched three lenders fail on it.

We use the Total Quality Lending Condo Questionnaire, built in house, with condo requirements written for our own DSCR product. That single difference is most of the story.

## What we did

Twenty-four days from the day the file came back to the day it funded. What sat inside those days:

**Ordered and paid for a new questionnaire.** The prior form was the wrong one. We fronted the $350 fee ourselves and told the borrowers that if we could not lend on the property, we would eat it. They never paid for it in the failure case.

**Chased an HOA that did not want to be chased.** Payment recorded late, a 72-hour turnaround promise that came and went, calls and escalation through the seller and the listing agent to get the form back at all.

**Fixed a unit count that did not add up.** The returned questionnaire reported 36 total units, and the unit-type breakdown on the same form totaled something else. Underwriting will not clear a contradiction. We went back and got it corrected.

**Answered an inspection date the HOA had marked unknown.** The management company wrote "unknown" for the date of the last inspection. Our underwriter needed an estimate. We got one.

**Secured an exception on the master policy.** The association's master policy carried less fidelity, crime, and employee dishonesty coverage than the guideline requires. We contacted the association's insurance carrier to confirm the endorsement, then took the file to the investor and got the exception approved.

**Sorted out the borrowers' own coverage.** They held a dwelling fire policy plus a separate wind policy. The file needed walls-in coverage to satisfy the condo requirement. We told their carrier exactly what underwriting had to see, and the policy was rewritten and cleared the day before the final approval.

**Transferred the appraisal.** We took the appraisal the previous lender had already ordered instead of ordering our own, which saved the fee and about a week off a clock that was already short.

**Pivoted to our DSCR Hybrid, same investor.** That appraisal had been ordered on a short-term rental form, and the rental income it came back with did not support the DSCR on the original product. Rather than start over, we moved the file to our DSCR Hybrid with the same investor, which let us underwrite off the appraisal already in hand and its rental schedule. No change to the borrowers' rate, term, or costs.

**Cleared the LLC file.** Signed operating agreement, certificate of good standing dated inside 120 days, and an addendum to the sales contract naming the LLC as the buyer.

**Coordinated a remote signing** with the title company so the borrowers, who live several states away, could sign and fund without flying to the coast.

## The result

Final approval came on a Friday afternoon. The borrowers signed remotely on Monday, their original contract close date, and the loan funded the next day.

We needed that one extra day and we absorbed the cost of it rather than passing it to them, so the terms they signed were the terms we quoted three weeks earlier. Their real estate agent did not celebrate the date. He apologized for the moving parts.

The reply from one of the borrowers: next time, a single-family home. They also told us they were done shopping. The next one comes straight to us.

## What to take from this

A rate is only a price on a loan that closes. If the loan does not close, you did not save a point. You lost the property, your earnest money deposit, the appraisal fee, and two weeks you cannot get back, and if the seller has already been burned once, you may not get a second contract at that price.

The appraisal is part of that math. Had they stayed with us, we would have underwritten the rental income from AirDNA data rather than a short-term rental appraisal form. That is a few hundred dollars less in appraisal cost, and it takes out the gamble on whether an appraiser comes back with the rents your loan actually needs. Theirs did not.

Before you pick a lender on a condo, ask three questions:

1. Which condo questionnaire will you use on this loan, and why that one?
2. Have you closed a non-warrantable condo in this market in the last 90 days?
3. What happens if the HOA refuses to answer an item on the form?

A lender who has done this work will answer all three in about a minute. A lender who has not will tell you it should be fine.

## We fund what others fear

Non-warrantable condos, condotels, short-term rentals, rural property, 5 to 8 units, foreign national. Total Quality Lending is a direct investment property lender with in-house underwriting, a dedicated condo document department, and one flat $1,790 fee covering underwriting and processing. No points, no origination, no junk fees.

If you are under contract on a condo and someone has already told you it cannot be financed, that is the deal we want to see. And if we cannot fund it, there is a good chance nobody can.
